Lapse f memry r distrted fairy tale?

HINDSIGHT may indeed be a wnderful thing (Letters, January 31) but nly if viewed frm the perspective f an accurate accunt f the facts. Certainly nt the distrted fairy tale painted by Cllr Petts, distilled fr the benefit f her wn narrw party p

HINDSIGHT may indeed be a wnderful thing (Letters, January 31) but nly if viewed frm the perspective f an accurate accunt f the facts. Certainly nt the distrted fairy tale painted by Cllr Petts, distilled fr the benefit f her wn narrw party plitical ends.

At the peak f this Try aberratin, csts had escalated t the unbelievable sum f £14.5 millin. Despite the faint prmise f a £3 millin grant frm Cambridgeshire Hrizns, the end result wuld have required the cuncil spending all its reserves; selling ff every piece f land it wned and still be left with a mrtgage f £6 millin t pay ff the lender fr the mney that they wuld need t have raised.

The cuncil wuld have been transfrmed frm being debt-free t being debt-ridden and it wuld have been a fallacy t say that it wuld have cst nthing. The financial cst expended by the cuncil in undertaking the evaluatin was in excess f £100,000.

Thrughut the evaluatin prcess and prir t the decisin f abandning the scheme there was n speculative supprt cming frward frm develpers and it culd easily have left the cuncil with the entire site and n partner.


You may also want to watch:


Events have shwn that Mantle Estates are prepared t take a gamble n develping its future. It is fr the sharehlders f the develper t take the risk f the site ever bearing fruit, nt the residents f East Cambs.

Cllr Petts cnveniently frgets it was the Independent members f the cuncil, tgether with a member f her wn grup wh, in the prevailing ecnmic climate, realised what a financial millstne the scheme wuld be fr East Cambs District Cuncil and residents and in uniting with the Lib Dems, brught the Try delusin t an end.

Most Read

Given that America is nw n the brink f recessin, large swathes f cmmercial prperty lie vacant and investrs are desperately trying t get ut f prperty funds, I believe the decisin taken at that pint in time t have been judicius.

Cllr Petts shuld stp believing in a pipe dream, and get her facts right. This is particularly evident in her respnse t the resident's letter where she culd nt even get the crrespndent's status crrect and shuld be magnanimus in aplgising t Mrs Gathercle fr the errr f assuming she was respnding t a man.

CLLR NEIL MORRISON

(Littleprt West Ward)

Nuthlt Lane

Ely

Become a Supporter

This newspaper has been a central part of community life for many years. Our industry faces testing times, which is why we're asking for your support. Every contribution will help us continue to produce local journalism that makes a measurable difference to our community.

Become a Supporter
Comments powered by Disqus