Council debate on charges to disposal of clinical waste in Fenland has councillors in conflict as ‘alternative options’ are promised

PUBLISHED: 18:36 13 September 2018

Cllr Virginia Bucknor at meeting at Fenland Hall on Thursday, September 13 2018. Picture: HARRY RUTTER

Cllr Virginia Bucknor at meeting at Fenland Hall on Thursday, September 13 2018. Picture: HARRY RUTTER

HARRY RUTTER

A heated debate about introducing a charge for clinical waste disposal in Fenland saw councillors at loggerheads and members of the public ejected from a meeting this afternoon (Thursday).

Meeting at Fenland Hall on Thursday, September 13 2018. Picture: HARRY RUTTERMeeting at Fenland Hall on Thursday, September 13 2018. Picture: HARRY RUTTER

It was decided that if the NHS are to bring in the charges next year, then the matter would be brought back to full council to see if “alternative options” could be considered.

More than 800 signatures were gathered on a petition against Fenland Council charging £8 for the collection of clinical waste and sharps boxes.

But councillors at today’s meeting at Fenland Hall were not swayed in favour of it, with various motions put forward until it was finally agreed that the decision would come after the NHS introduced the charges.

Sue Marshall, who presented the council with the petition, told councillors that if they were to support the charges they would be “acting unfairly and lacking any compassion for the vulnerable or elderly.”

Cllr Chris Seaton, lead, at meeting at Fenland Hall on Thursday, September 13 2018. Picture: HARRY RUTTERCllr Chris Seaton, lead, at meeting at Fenland Hall on Thursday, September 13 2018. Picture: HARRY RUTTER

“Shame on you Fenland if you bring in the charge on clinical waste,” was also the message from campaigner councillor Virginia Bucknor.

She said: “We were given ludicrous information in July about these charges without any discussion. It is not logical or sensible and will effect the vulnerable in our society.”

Two members of the public were asked to leave as the meeting was almost suspended when shouts of “how would you feel” and “shame on you” were echoed from the gallery as members swayed between motions.

Councillor Peter Murphy, cabinet member, emphasised that it was not the decision of the council but the NHS that would force them to implement the charges.

Cllr Virginia Bucknor, back row, centre, at meeting at Fenland Hall on Thursday, September 13 2018. Picture: HARRY RUTTERCllr Virginia Bucknor, back row, centre, at meeting at Fenland Hall on Thursday, September 13 2018. Picture: HARRY RUTTER

“This would involve specialist equipment and trained staff and the charges would be considerable for us, we’re talking around £130,000 a year,” he said.

“We do not want to do this but will have no choice if the NHS introduce it.

“I think you are over-hyping this and it’s not as bad as you make it out to be.”

Cllr Bucknor said after the meeting: “Well, the usual fancy footwork was done by the Conservatives today.

Cllr Peter Murphy, cabinet member, at meeting at Fenland Hall on Thursday, September 13 2018. Picture: HARRY RUTTERCllr Peter Murphy, cabinet member, at meeting at Fenland Hall on Thursday, September 13 2018. Picture: HARRY RUTTER

“They voted against supporting the petition despite the 881 votes from residents.

“Although they had advised councillors in several emails that they would be charging £8 from September 1, then deferred until January 1, they amended today’s motion - not to support the petition but in favour of “when the NHS introduce this, before making any decisions it will be brought back to council”.

She said: “We at least got the council not to just rubber stamp this charge and it will come back for councillors to agree.”

Cllrs Alex Miscandlon (left) and Cllr Steve Count at meeting at Fenland Hall on Thursday, September 13 2018. Picture: HARRY RUTTERCllrs Alex Miscandlon (left) and Cllr Steve Count at meeting at Fenland Hall on Thursday, September 13 2018. Picture: HARRY RUTTER

Cllr David Oliver, cabinet member, at meeting at Fenland Hall on Thursday, September 13 2018. Picture: HARRY RUTTERCllr David Oliver, cabinet member, at meeting at Fenland Hall on Thursday, September 13 2018. Picture: HARRY RUTTER

Cllr Dee Laws, cabinet member, at meeting at Fenland Hall on Thursday, September 13 2018. Picture: HARRY RUTTERCllr Dee Laws, cabinet member, at meeting at Fenland Hall on Thursday, September 13 2018. Picture: HARRY RUTTER

Chief executive Paul Medd at meeting at Fenland Hall on Thursday, September 13 2018. Picture: HARRY RUTTERChief executive Paul Medd at meeting at Fenland Hall on Thursday, September 13 2018. Picture: HARRY RUTTER

0 comments

Welcome , please leave your message below.

Optional - JPG files only
Optional - MP3 files only
Optional - 3GP, AVI, MOV, MPG or WMV files
Comments

Please log in to leave a comment and share your views with other Ely Standard visitors.

We enable people to post comments with the aim of encouraging open debate.

Only people who register and sign up to our terms and conditions can post comments. These terms and conditions explain our house rules and legal guidelines.

Comments are not edited by Ely Standard staff prior to publication but may be automatically filtered.

If you have a complaint about a comment please contact us by clicking on the Report This Comment button next to the comment.

Not a member yet?

Register to create your own unique Ely Standard account for free.

Signing up is free, quick and easy and offers you the chance to add comments, personalise the site with local information picked just for you, and more.

Sign up now

More news stories

Yesterday, 17:44

Owners of a Haddenham house unknowingly being used to grow cannabis thanked police “for all their good work and commend them on their professionalism in dealing with this complex situation”.

Yesterday, 15:15

A schoolboy, who organised two football matches for East Anglia’s Children’s Hospices (EACH), netting £22,509, is to cut the ribbon at the charity’s new shop in Ely.

Yesterday, 17:58

Will they go all the way? Well you’ll have to get tickets to The Full Monty in Ely to find out.

Yesterday, 11:56

An 83-year-old Cambridgeshire man who was jailed for 18 sexual offences against four girls has had his prison term increased by seven years after an appeal against his sentence.

Most read stories

Most commented stories

Digital Edition

Image
Read the Ely Standard e-edition E-edition

Show Job Lists

Newsletter Sign Up

Ely Standard weekly newsletter
Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Our Privacy Policy